I should really turn my eBay notifications off and look at my actual cards. It’s a rabbit hole—and not a healthy one. If I’m being honest, I probably get even less out of it than I think I do, and my expectations are already on the floor. What real value is there in seeing another $8,000 card I’ll never own? By the time I finally have the funds, it’s already been scooped up by someone less dedicated than me. Brutal. The hobby, as many of you know, is a cycle. A vicious one. Collectors are rarely satisfied. A “grail” one day becomes just another card sleeved and shelved the next—forgotten in pursuit of something bigger and flashier. Because the hobby is also an echo chamber, where the chase often drowns out the joy. So, I propose an unethical solution. This may hurt a few of you, and if so, my condolences: Take them out of their top loaders and one-touches. Feel their weight. See how they sit in your palm. It’s surprisingly fun to figure out what material you prefer. Me? I’m a sucker for a thick, multi-layered relic. There’s something about the heft—it adds a kind of gravity. Like, yeah, this guy wore that piece of jersey, and I know it, because this chunk of cardboard feels substantial. Weird to say? Maybe. But it’s real. We’ve become obsessed with value in this hobby. Cards must be investments. They can’t just be for pleasure. And I get it—if you’re spending hundreds or thousands, you want some sort of return. But that mindset also means we imprison our cards. We lock them away in little plastic cells so they stay pristine for the next buyer. That, to me, is bleak. It’s like raising a kid solely to be a perfect spouse for someone else. Ridiculous, right? And if you’re careful? Your cards will stay clean and feel loved. A final thought: #CollectorsMD —
“There are new results for your saved searches.” Yeah? And what about it?
Hold your cards.
These cards are ours. For now. Maybe forever. So cherish them. Let them breathe. Let them feel the warmth of your hands, the care of human touch. I’m not saying condition doesn’t matter—I prefer a clean card too—but a soft corner or surface smudge won’t matter as much in the long run as a real connection to your collection.
Are you really getting your money’s worth if you don’t even know what the card feels like in your hands?
We collect to connect—not to hoard.
Follow us on Instagram: @collectorsmd
Subscribe to our Newsletter & Support Group
Join The Conversation On Mantel